Which of the following is a problem for Kant's principle of equality and an "eye for an eye" according to Nathanson?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Nathanson argues that Kant's principle of equality and an "eye for an eye" face multiple problems. Firstly, it fails to provide a clear and consistent measure for determining the appropriate punishment for all crimes. Secondly, it does not adequately consider the nuances of individual cases and whether the punishment is proportional to the crime committed. Finally, it can require punishments that are considered morally unacceptable, such as capital punishment or torture, which violate the principle of human dignity. Therefore, all of the above (A, B, and C) are problematic for Kant's principle.

Which of the Following Is a Problem for Kant's Principle