What does Hursthouse say about the claim that any adequate action-guiding (i.e., moral) theory must provide clear guidance about what ought and ought not to be done that any intelligent person could follow?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Hursthouse argues that this claim is implausible because moral decision-making is complex and context-dependent. She contends that any theory that simplifies ethical decision-making to a set of clear-cut rules would be inadequate and fail to capture the nuance and complexity of moral reasoning. Instead, a moral theory should provide general guidelines that can be applied to specific situations, but ultimately allow for flexibility and judgment in making ethical judgments.

What Does Hursthouse Say About the Claim That Any Adequate