Which is the best standard-form representation of the following Argument from Analogy?
Suppose a photographer takes pictures for all sorts of different events but refuses to do children's birthday parties, because they don't feel comfortable around children. Clearly, this photographer has a right to refuse to do children's birthday parties without being penalized. Some Christian bakery owners have refused to sell cakes to same-sex couples because they don't feel comfortable around gay people. These cases are morally identical. Therefore, Christian bakers have the right to refuse to sell cakes to same-sex couples without being penalized.
A) 1) A photographer who is uncomfortable around children has a right to refuse to do children's birthday parties without being penalized.
2) A bakery owner who is uncomfortable around gay people is relevantly similar to a photographer who is uncomfortable around children.
Therefore, a baker has a right to refuse to sell cakes to gay people without being penalized.
B) 1) A baker has a right to refuse to sell cakes to gay people without being penalized.
2) A bakery owner who is uncomfortable around gay people is relevantly similar to a photographer who is uncomfortable around children.
Therefore, a photographer who is uncomfortable around children has a right to refuse to do children's birthday parties without being penalized.
C) 1) A baker has a right to refuse to sell cakes to gay people without being penalized.
2) A photographer who is uncomfortable around children has a right to refuse to do children's birthday parties without being penalized.
Therefore, people have a right not to do things that make them uncomfortable.
D) 1) A photographer who is uncomfortable around children has a right to refuse to do children's birthday parties without being penalized.
2) People have a right not to do things that make them uncomfortable. Therefore, a baker has a right to refuse to sell cakes to gay people without being penalized.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The argument from analogy compares two situations: a photographer refusing to work at children's parties and a baker refusing to sell cakes to same-sex couples. Choice A correctly represents the argument's structure by stating the photographer's right and drawing a parallel to the baker's situation.

Which Is the Best Standard-Form Representation of the Following Argument