Below is an Argument from Analogy in standard form. In 2 to 4 short paragraphs, do the following:
-First [1 point], suggest what you think is the best candidate for a genuine and morally relevant disanalogy between the cases being compared. "Premise 2 is false because…"
-Second [1 point], test your suggested disanalogy for moral relevance. Be sure to describe your relevance test and explain what it shows.
The argument:
[note: Plan B birth control is a pill you can take up to 72 hours after sex (for instance if protection was not used or the protection, such as a condom, failed) to prevent pregnancy. It works by preventing the newly fertilized egg from implanting in the uterus. Some people are opposed to the use of Plan B because they view it as wrong for the same reasons they think abortion is wrong.]
1) A vegetarian pharmacist has an obligation to fill medications that (because they were tested on animals) conflict with her personal values.
2)Anti-abortion pharmacists refusing to fill Plan B prescriptions because of personal objections is relevantly similar to vegetarian pharmacists refusing to fill medications tested on animals because of personal objections.
So, an anti-abortion pharmacist has a moral obligation to fill a Plan B prescription even if that conflicts with her personal values.
Correct Answer:
Answered by Quizplus AI
View Answer
Unlock this answer now
Get Access to more Verified Answers free of charge
Q6: Below is an Argument from Analogy along
Q7: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q8: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q9: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q10: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q11: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q12: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q13: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q15: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Q16: Below is an Argument from Analogy in
Unlock this Answer For Free Now!
View this answer and more for free by performing one of the following actions
Scan the QR code to install the App and get 2 free unlocks
Unlock quizzes for free by uploading documents