If the mental or physical condition of a party to a suit is an issue raised by the other party the:
A) court cannot require an examination since that violates the constitutional right to privacy about medical issues
B) court will only allow evidence from the experts of the plaintiff's choosing
C) court will sanction a rule to comply
D) party requesting the order must show a greater need for this information than for other kinds of discovery
E) none of the other choices are correct

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The party requesting the order must show a greater need for information about the mental or physical condition of the other party than for other kinds of discovery. This is because medical information is generally considered private and is protected under various laws and regulations. However, if the information is relevant and necessary to the case, the court may order the party to undergo a medical examination or produce medical records. The court will balance the need for the information against the privacy interests of the party.

If the Mental or Physical Condition of a Party to a Suit