Rudy's wife, Pamela, makes a pumpkin pie for him, which is one of his favorite desserts. After eating two slices of the pie, Rudy makes a general remark that a pumpkin pie is best enjoyed during Thanksgiving. Pamela concludes that Rudy does not like the pumpkin pie that she made and decides to avoid making pies for him in the future. Based on the given information, Pamela has most likely committed _____.
A) the straw man fallacy
B) the red herring fallacy
C) the fallacy of personal attack
D) the fallacy of appeal to pity

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Pamela has committed the straw man fallacy by misinterpreting Rudy's general statement about enjoying pumpkin pie during Thanksgiving as a critique of her pie, rather than addressing his actual comment.

Rudy's Wife, Pamela, Makes a Pumpkin Pie for Him, Which