Part of what Thomson's Transplant Problem thought experiment shows is
A) the stark difference between a utilitarian and a nonutilitarian solution to the transplant problem.
B) that taking one life to save others is always morally permissible.
C) that in life-and-death situations, murder is always an acceptable option.
D) transplants are immoral.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Thomson's Transplant Problem thought experiment is used to illustrate the ethical dilemma between utilitarian principles, which might justify sacrificing one life to save several, and deontological or rights-based ethics, which would argue against taking a life regardless of the outcome. It highlights the conflict between these ethical frameworks rather than endorsing the permissibility of murder or the immorality of transplants.

Part of What Thomson's Transplant Problem Thought Experiment Shows Is