The Nestor and Thersites thought experiment is intended to show that
A) souls are not distinct from the thoughts they have.
B) being the same person does not require having the same soul.
C) being the same person requires having the same soul.
D) souls are identical to thoughts.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Nestor and Thersites thought experiment, often associated with discussions on personal identity, suggests that if the memories and personalities of two individuals were to be swapped, their identities would effectively swap as well, despite their souls (in a metaphysical sense) remaining in their original bodies. This implies that being the same person does not necessarily require having the same soul, challenging the idea that a soul is the sole bearer of personal identity.

The Nestor and Thersites Thought Experiment Is Intended to Show