According to Smilansky, compatibilists can have no principled reason for not punishing those who have a high probability of committing a crime.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Compatibilists believe that free will is compatible with determinism, and that people are responsible for their actions even if those actions are caused by factors beyond their control. Therefore, they would have no principled reason for not punishing those who have a high probability of committing a crime, as they believe that these individuals are still responsible for their actions.

According to Smilansky, Compatibilists Can Have No Principled Reason for Not