Searle's Brain Replacement thought experiment is intended to show that
A) both the identity theory and logical behaviorism are mistaken.
B) the identity theory is unfounded, but logical behaviorism is TRUE.
C) both the identity theory and logical behaviorism are TRUE.
D) neurons function like artificial devises.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Searle's Brain Replacement thought experiment is designed to critique both the identity theory, which equates mental states with brain states, and logical behaviorism, which reduces mental states to behavioral dispositions. It suggests that even if a brain were replaced by artificial parts that replicated the functions of neurons, the subjective experience or consciousness might not be preserved, challenging the assumptions of both theories about the nature of mind and mental states.

Searle's Brain Replacement Thought Experiment Is Intended to Show That