Reiman argues that just because a murder deserves to die, it does not follow that society ought to execute the murderer. Consider a parallel claim. Just because a student deserves an "A" on the paper she wrote, it does not follow that the professor should give the student the deserved "A".

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Reiman argues that just because a murder deserves to die, it does not follow that society ought to execute the murderer. Consider a parallel claim. Just because a student deserves an "A" on the paper she wrote, it does not follow that the professor should give the student the deserved "A".

Reiman Argues That Just Because a Murder Deserves to Die