What Would You Do?
You are Bear Lake's chief of police. You witnessed the scene when Smith brought Horne in; you also noticed Horne's condition and couldn't help but notice his loud rantings against his arresting officer. You are faced with a dilemma. On one hand, you know that Horne is a career criminal and are 95 percent sure he's the one responsible for the eight home burglaries being investigated. You also know that his cousin is a local lawyer who has defended him for years and managed to keep his jail time down to a minimum. You understand that a confession is the only thing that will put Horne in jail for what you'd consider a "just amount of time." Lastly, you consider that Horne has filed a police brutality complaint against Smith once before, and believe this might be the suspect's most recent tactic toward undermining the strength of the case against him.
On the other hand, you have worked with Smith for the last five years and recognize that he often skirts the letter of the law to maintain "what's just and right" in his own mind. He has been known to be careless with details on police reports, having been caught embellishing the facts on three known occasions and purposefully omitting facts two other times. Twice in the last two years, he's been caught sleeping in his patrol car when he was on duty, and six years ago he was accused of offering to "make charges go away" in exchange for sex with a local businesswoman who was arrested, though nothing ever came of those accusations. In the back of your mind, you realize that Smith probably roughed up Horne so that the charges would stick this time and that he was only doing what he thought was right.
-You are faced with the option of ignoring Horne's complaint or filing a police brutality complaint against Smith on his behalf. What do you do?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of What Would You Do?
You are Bear Lake's chief of police. You witnessed the scene when Smith brought Horne in; you also noticed Horne's condition and couldn't help but notice his loud rantings against his arresting officer. You are faced with a dilemma. On one hand, you know that Horne is a career criminal and are 95 percent sure he's the one responsible for the eight home burglaries being investigated. You also know that his cousin is a local lawyer who has defended him for years and managed to keep his jail time down to a minimum. You understand that a confession is the only thing that will put Horne in jail for what you'd consider a "just amount of time." Lastly, you consider that Horne has filed a police brutality complaint against Smith once before, and believe this might be the suspect's most recent tactic toward undermining the strength of the case against him.
On the other hand, you have worked with Smith for the last five years and recognize that he often skirts the letter of the law to maintain "what's just and right" in his own mind. He has been known to be careless with details on police reports, having been caught embellishing the facts on three known occasions and purposefully omitting facts two other times. Twice in the last two years, he's been caught sleeping in his patrol car when he was on duty, and six years ago he was accused of offering to "make charges go away" in exchange for sex with a local businesswoman who was arrested, though nothing ever came of those accusations. In the back of your mind, you realize that Smith probably roughed up Horne so that the charges would stick this time and that he was only doing what he thought was right.
-You are faced with the option of ignoring Horne's complaint or filing a police brutality complaint against Smith on his behalf. What do you do?