Which of the following, if True, would weaken Santora's argument?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

B) Santora believes that the organization has demonstrated a lack of commitment to diversity. The evidence backs up this belief. Having no minorities among upper management is not a good sign. However, if Choice B is True, then there's an alternative explanation for this failure. All the minority employees have one year of experience or less, and if candidates for upper management positions need three years or more, then those current employees haven't been there long enough. Choice B doesn't prove the argument, but it does make it more likely. Choice A makes the argument stronger by suggesting that openings arise frequently. Choice C, if anything, suggests that the organization made no special efforts to recruit candidates. That would work against Santora's argument. Choice D tells us about the requirements of the job but nothing about the earnestness of the organization's efforts. Choice E suggests that some problems existed in the past. If anything, the severity of those problems would strengthen Santora's argument.

Which of the Following, If True, Would Weaken Santora's Argument