The case of the "deathbed promise" shows that
A)utilitarianism may lead to conclusions that conflict with commonsense morality.
B)keeping your promises never maximizes happiness.
C)it was wrong to have made the promise in the first place.
D)utilitarianism boils down to egoism.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The case highlights a conflict between utilitarianism and commonsense morality, where keeping a deathbed promise to a friend causes harm to many other individuals. This demonstrates that following utilitarian principles may lead to conclusions that conflict with our usual moral intuitions. The other options are not supported by the case.

The Case of the "Deathbed Promise" Shows That