Which critical appraisal question would evaluate the review of the literature of a research report?
A) Is there a synthesis summary that presents the overall strengths and weaknesses and arrives at a logical conclusion that generates hypotheses or research questions?
B) What are the sources of bias, and are they dealt with appropriately?
C) How have the purpose, aims, or goals of the study been substantiated?
D) To what population may the findings be generalized? What are the limitations in generalizability?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Option A is the most appropriate critical appraisal question to evaluate the review of the literature in a research report. It assesses whether the review provides a synthesis summary of the overall strengths and weaknesses of the existing literature and arrives at a logical conclusion that generates hypotheses or research questions. This question helps to determine whether the review is comprehensive, well-organized, and relevant to the research question.
Option B is a critical appraisal question that evaluates the methodology of a research study and how potential sources of bias have been addressed. Option C is a critical appraisal question that assesses the justification and clarity of the research aims and objectives. Option D is a critical appraisal question that evaluates the external validity and generalizability of the study findings. While these questions are essential in the critical appraisal of research, they are not specific to evaluating the review of the literature.

Which Critical Appraisal Question Would Evaluate the Review of the Literature