In evaluating which judicial selection system is best it is important to determine if one system produces better judges than another. Judicial folklore has long held that particular systems may produce superior judges. Several studies have systematically analyzed this folklore. Researchers use measurable judicial credentials, such as education and prior legal experience, as indicators of judicial quality.
-Which system is likely to produce judges who have held political office?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The election system is the most likely to produce judges who have held political office, as they must run for public office and campaign for votes. In contrast, the appointment system and merit system often prioritize qualifications and experience in the legal field over political experience. The Missouri system, while involving a retention election, does not require judges to campaign or run for office.

In Evaluating Which Judicial Selection System Is Best It Is