Narrative 2-2
Brain Imaging
Katherine is a researcher studying the neurophysiology of schizophrenia.In order to do so,she compares fMRI imaging when individuals are on effective medication and when they have been off their medication long enough that it is no longer detectible in their blood.
-Katherine is aware that some potential participants may have cognitive impairments and she considers excluding them solely on that basis.At the same time,she is aware that participants may,themselves,benefit from participating in the study,since they will live in at research hospital during the study and will have access to numerous resources while hospitalized.If Katherine decides to exclude persons with cognitive impairments,she is also denying these individuals access to other services,and this bothers her.In terms of the principles in the Belmont Report,she is struggling with issues related to ____.
A)respect for persons
B)beneficence
C)justice
D)voluntariness

Question

​Narrative 2-2
Brain Imaging
Katherine is a researcher studying the neurophysiology of schizophrenia.In order to do so,she compares fMRI imaging when individuals are on effective medication and when they have been off their medication long enough that it is no longer detectible in their blood.
-Katherine is aware that some potential participants may have cognitive impairments and she considers excluding them solely on that basis.At the same time,she is aware that participants may,themselves,benefit from participating in the study,since they will live in at research hospital during the study and will have access to numerous resources while hospitalized.If Katherine decides to exclude persons with cognitive impairments,she is also denying these individuals access to other services,and this bothers her.In terms of the principles in the Belmont Report,she is struggling with issues related to ____.
A)respect for persons​
B)beneficence
C)justice
D)voluntariness

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Katherine is struggling with the principle of justice, as she is faced with the ethical dilemma of denying individuals with cognitive impairments access to the study and the resources available at the research hospital. This decision could potentially be seen as unfair or unjust, as it may deprive certain individuals of the same opportunities as others. However, she is also tasked with balancing this principle with others, such as beneficence and respect for persons.

​Narrative 2-2 Brain Imaging

Narrative 2-2 Brain Imaging