Amber Blue owns a small hotel of the "bed & breakfast" variety.Hunter Greene,a tenant at Blue's bed & breakfast,sustained severe physical injuries when an intruder broke into Greene's room and attacked him with a baseball bat.The intruder was neither an employee of Blue's nor otherwise had any connection with Blue's bed & breakfast.Greene filed a tort action against Blue in an effort to collect damages for the medical expenses,lost earnings,and pain and suffering he experienced as a result of the intruder's attack.Greene argued that owners of commercial property such as a bed & breakfast are liable,as a matter of law,whenever guests are injured while on the premises.Blue argued that such property owners cannot be held liable when the guest's injuries were directly (and criminally)inflicted by a third-party attacker.Evaluate the arguments made,respectively,by Greene and Blue.Explain your supporting reasoning.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Amber Blue owns a small hotel of the "bed & breakfast" variety.Hunter Greene,a tenant at Blue's bed & breakfast,sustained severe physical injuries when an intruder broke into Greene's room and attacked him with a baseball bat.The intruder was neither an employee of Blue's nor otherwise had any connection with Blue's bed & breakfast.Greene filed a tort action against Blue in an effort to collect damages for the medical expenses,lost earnings,and pain and suffering he experienced as a result of the intruder's attack.Greene argued that owners of commercial property such as a bed & breakfast are liable,as a matter of law,whenever guests are injured while on the premises.Blue argued that such property owners cannot be held liable when the guest's injuries were directly (and criminally)inflicted by a third-party attacker.Evaluate the arguments made,respectively,by Greene and Blue.Explain your supporting reasoning.

Amber Blue Owns a Small Hotel of the "Bed