In determining whether or not the decision of an administrative tribunal is subject to judicial review, which of the following would not be a relevant question?
A) Did the tribunal make the same decision that a court would have made?
B) Is the statute that created the tribunal ultra vires under the Constitution Act, 1867?
C) Is the statute that created the tribunal consistent with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms?
D) Is the tribunal acting within the power given to it by statute?
E) Did the tribunal follow the rules of natural justice?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The question of whether a tribunal made the same decision that a court would have made is not relevant to determining if its decision is subject to judicial review. Judicial review focuses on legality, jurisdiction, and adherence to principles of natural justice, not on mirroring court decisions.

In Determining Whether or Not the Decision of an Administrative