Identify a criticism by Melvin Tumin on the Davis-Moore thesis.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Melvin Tumin criticized the Davis-Moore thesis by arguing that there is little association between earnings and the jobs that keep a society going. Tumin suggested that the criteria used to determine the importance of a position are subjective and vary across societies. He also argued that the assumption that some positions are more crucial than others for a society's survival oversimplifies the complexities of modern societies. In sum, Tumin's criticism challenges the idea that social stratification is based on meritocracy.

Identify a Criticism by Melvin Tumin on the Davis-Moore Thesis