If you, as a farmer, have a bumper crop this year you will make more money.If all farmers have a bumper crop this year, all farmers will make more money.What kind of fallacy does this statement exhibit?
A)post hoc fallacy.
B)failure to hold other things constant fallacy.
C)fallacy of composition.
D)fallacy of normalcy.
E)None of the above.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

This statement exhibits the fallacy of composition, which is the assumption that what is true for one part of a group is true for the whole group. In this case, it is assumed that if one farmer has a bumper crop, then all farmers having a bumper crop would lead to the same outcome. However, this assumption does not take into account other factors that could affect the market, such as supply and demand, which could actually result in lower prices and less profit for individual farmers.

If You, as a Farmer, Have a Bumper Crop This