With Reference to the Graph Above,if the Intended Aim of the Price

With reference to the graph above,if the intended aim of the price ceiling shown was a net increase in the well-being of consumers,then positive analysis would conclude:

A) the policy was effective,since area A + C is larger than B + D.
B) the policy was effective,since area B is smaller than area D.
C) the policy was ineffective,since D is larger than E.
D) the policy was ineffective,since A + C + D is larger than B + E.