In this pair of cases,the first may serve as precedent for the second.Decide whether the second case is so relevantly similar to the first that it should be decided identically.Explain your decision.
First case:Officers arrested D in his living room on a charge of using the mails to transport forged checks.Then they searched the other rooms of his apartment for forged checks,which they did not find.But they did find unlawfully possessed draft cards.D was convicted of possession and alteration of the draft cards.The court held the search was lawful as incidental to a valid arrest.
Second case:Federal officers had observed the defendant operating an illegal still.They entered the premises and made a valid arrest without a warrant for a felony committed in their presence.They seized the still.At trial,the defendant moved to exclude the still from evidence.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of In this pair of cases,the first may serve as precedent for the second.Decide whether the second case is so relevantly similar to the first that it should be decided identically.Explain your decision.
First case:Officers arrested D in his living room on a charge of using the mails to transport forged checks.Then they searched the other rooms of his apartment for forged checks,which they did not find.But they did find unlawfully possessed draft cards.D was convicted of possession and alteration of the draft cards.The court held the search was lawful as incidental to a valid arrest.
Second case:Federal officers had observed the defendant operating an illegal still.They entered the premises and made a valid arrest without a warrant for a felony committed in their presence.They seized the still.At trial,the defendant moved to exclude the still from evidence.

In This Pair of Cases,the First May Serve as Precedent