Cedile Trailer Supply Has Received Three Proposals for Its New

Cedile Trailer Supply has received three proposals for its new trailer assembly line.Information on each proposal is as follows:
$$\begin{array} { | l | r | r | r | } \hline & \text { Proposal X } & \text { Proposal Y } & \text { Proposal Z } \\\hline \text { Initial investment in equipment } & \$ 180,000 & \$ 140,000 & \$ 145,000 \\\hline \text { Working capital needed } & 0 & 0 & 15,000 \\\hline \text { Annual cash saved by operations: } & & & \\\hline \text { Year 1 } & 60,000 & 60,000 & 60,000 \\\hline \text { Year 2 } & 60,000 & 50,000 & 60,000 \\\hline \text { Year 3 } & 60,000 & 35,000 & 60,000 \\\hline \text { Year 4 } & 60,000 & 10,000 & 60,000 \\\hline \text { Salvage value end of year: } & & & \\\hline \text { Year 1 } & 30,000 & 25,000 & 45,000 \\\hline \text { Year 2 } & 25,000 & 20,000 & 40,000 \\\hline \text { Year 3 } & 20,000 & 15,000 & 35,000 \\\hline \text { Year 4 } & 15,000 & 10,000 & 25,000 \\\hline \text { Working capital returned: } & 0 & 0 & 15,000 \\\hline\end{array}$$ Required:
Determine each proposal's payback.