A court may rule contrary to a precedent if the court decides that the precedent

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

A court may rule contrary to a precedent if it decides that the precedent is incorrect or inapplicable. This is because the precedent may not have considered certain facts or circumstances that are relevant to the current case or may have been decided incorrectly. In such situations, the court may depart from the precedent to arrive at a just and fair decision in the present case. However, it is not appropriate for a court to depart from a precedent simply because it is not in line with the judge's personal values or preferences, or because it would lead to unintended consequences.

A Court May Rule Contrary to a Precedent If the Court