The following fallacy is an example of a faulty analogy: "Last semester,I had an excellent student whose last name was Whipple.This semester,I have another student with that name,and I'm expecting good work from her.".

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The argument relies on an analogy between two individuals based solely on their shared last name. The fact that one student performed well does not necessarily mean another student with the same last name will also perform well. Thus, the conclusion cannot be validly drawn, making it a faulty analogy.

The Following Fallacy Is an Example of a Faulty Analogy