Fact Pattern 3-B1
Orin and Pia engage in a business transaction from which a dispute arises.Orin initiates a lawsuit against Pia by filing a complaint.
-Solar Power,Inc. ,files a suit against Thunder Bay Utility Company and seeks to examine certain documents in Thunder's possession.A legitimate reason for this examination is that the documents contain
A)evidence about the case.
B)private information about Thunder's operations.
C)public information about energy generation.
D)irrelevant data that can be eliminated from consideration.

Question

Fact Pattern 3-B1 
Orin and Pia engage in a business transaction from which a dispute arises.Orin initiates a lawsuit against Pia by filing a complaint.
-Solar Power,Inc. ,files a suit against Thunder Bay Utility Company and seeks to examine certain documents in Thunder's possession.A legitimate reason for this examination is that the documents contain
A)evidence about the case.
B)private information about Thunder's operations.
C)public information about energy generation.
D)irrelevant data that can be eliminated from consideration.

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Solar Power, Inc. is seeking to examine certain documents in Thunder Bay Utility Company's possession for a legitimate reason, which is that the documents contain evidence about the case. Therefore, option A is the best choice. Option B is incorrect because private information about Thunder's operations is not relevant to the lawsuit. Option C is also incorrect because public information about energy generation is not necessarily relevant to the case at hand. Option D is incorrect because if the data is truly irrelevant, there would be no reason for Solar Power, Inc. to seek to examine it in the first place.