What justifies my belief "the cat is on the mat" is
A) just the singular fact that the cat is on the mat.
B) my innate ideas of cats and mats.
C) whether uttering this statement "feels right" to me.
D) an array of visual and sensory evidence,as well as the coherence of that belief with many other beliefs I have.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

D is the best choice as it reflects the importance of evidence and coherence in justifying a belief. A single fact may not be enough to justify a belief, as it could be a coincidence or misperception. Innate ideas or subjective feelings also cannot be used as reliable justifications. The best justification comes from a combination of sensory evidence and the coherence of the belief with other beliefs you hold.

What Justifies My Belief "The Cat Is on the Mat