Two research teams are both experimenting with new treatments for a medical condition. In one study, the condition involved currently has no treatment; in the other, there is an accepted treatment, to which the researchers seek alternative and/or improved options. Both studies are comparing an experimental treatment to a placebo. Ethically, what is the most likely opinion?

Question

​Two research teams are both experimenting with new treatments for a medical condition. In one study, the condition involved currently has no treatment; in the other, there is an accepted treatment, to which the researchers seek alternative and/or improved options. Both studies are comparing an experimental treatment to a placebo. Ethically, what is the most likely opinion?

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The study where an accepted standard of care exists may be considered unethical if a placebo is used instead of the standard treatment, as this could deprive participants of effective therapy. In contrast, using a placebo in a condition with no current treatment does not withhold established therapies.

​Two Research Teams Are Both Experimenting with New Treatments for a Medical

Two Research Teams Are Both Experimenting with New Treatments for a Medical