Suppose Two Young Men Had Taken a Test of Intelligence

Suppose two young men had taken a test of intelligence. Ralph believed he did very well, and Fred believed he did poorly. Both have the occasion to meet a young woman. Which of the following best describes how they would most likely react based on her physical attractiveness?

A) Ralph would like her more if she were attractive, Fred if she were unattractive.
B) Fred would like her more if she were attractive, Ralph if she were unattractive.
C) Ralph and Fred would both like her more if she were attractive.
D) In this instance, attractiveness would not be related to how much the men liked the woman.