Case Study
Jacob and Diana are spouses who have an extremely close relationship. They have a "no secrets" policy-they tell each other nearly everything and never keep anything important from each other. The only things they ever keep secret are things like gifts or surprise parties. They believe that this degree of openness and trust allows them to have a deeper and more meaningful relationship than would otherwise be possible.
Recently, Jacob's childhood friend Nicole revealed to him a dark, traumatic secret from her past. Nicole, distraught, asked Jacob to promise her not to repeat it to anyone, and Jacob, not wanting to upset her in the moment, agreed. But soon after, Jacob realized that keeping his promise would mean keeping something important for Diana, which would violate her trust. Diana knows Nicole but is much less close with her, so Jacob understands why Nicole would not want her to know. But he and Diana tell each other everything-that's just how it is.
-Does the fact that this case involves interpersonal relationships make a feminist ethical approach particularly apt? Is a feminist approach generally more useful than a traditional approach when it comes to the ethics of relationships? Why or why not?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Case Study
Jacob and Diana are spouses who have an extremely close relationship. They have a "no secrets" policy-they tell each other nearly everything and never keep anything important from each other. The only things they ever keep secret are things like gifts or surprise parties. They believe that this degree of openness and trust allows them to have a deeper and more meaningful relationship than would otherwise be possible.
Recently, Jacob's childhood friend Nicole revealed to him a dark, traumatic secret from her past. Nicole, distraught, asked Jacob to promise her not to repeat it to anyone, and Jacob, not wanting to upset her in the moment, agreed. But soon after, Jacob realized that keeping his promise would mean keeping something important for Diana, which would violate her trust. Diana knows Nicole but is much less close with her, so Jacob understands why Nicole would not want her to know. But he and Diana tell each other everything-that's just how it is.
-Does the fact that this case involves interpersonal relationships make a feminist ethical approach particularly apt? Is a feminist approach generally more useful than a traditional approach when it comes to the ethics of relationships? Why or why not?

Case Study Jacob and Diana Are Spouses Who Have an Extremely Close