Describe the sort of case about which Nicholas Dixon and Katie Roiphe would disagree. (That is, Dixon would say that it was wrong to have sex in those circumstances, whereas Roiphe wouldn't.) Explain their disagreement, and then either (a) take a side and justify your choice or (b) offer a perspective on the case that differs from both Dixon's and Roiphe's.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is -Describe a case in which Dixon would say that one party fails to meet the "communicative sexuality" standard, and so is wrong, whereas Roiphe would say that having sex is OK. (Example: a casual sexual encounter involving a moderate amount of alcohol where both parties are giving strong nonverbal signals in favor of wanting to have sex, but there is no explicit question and answer about having sex.)
-Explain why Dixon and Roiphe disagree (Dixon thinks the standard for securing consent alters when alcohol is involved; Roiphe thinks that we're at risk of denying female sexual agency).
-Reasonably explain agreement with Dixon or Roiphe or offer an alternative perspective.

Describe the Sort of Case About Which Nicholas Dixon and Katie