What is the point of Thomson's example where Jones steals Smith's coat that both men need to keep themselves from freezing?
A) Jones has the moral right to steal Smith's coat if that is his only means of survival
B) Someone with the job of securing people's rights both can and should help Smith
C) It would be cold, cruel, and callous for Smith to refuse his coat to Jones
D) Everyone should have the right to refuse to intervene in Jones and Smith's private conflict
E) Justice demands that Jones and Smith find a way to both share the coat

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of What is the point of Thomson's example where Jones steals Smith's coat that both men need to keep themselves from freezing?
A) Jones has the moral right to steal Smith's coat if that is his only means of survival
B) Someone with the job of securing people's rights both can and should help Smith
C) It would be cold, cruel, and callous for Smith to refuse his coat to Jones
D) Everyone should have the right to refuse to intervene in Jones and Smith's private conflict
E) Justice demands that Jones and Smith find a way to both share the coat

What Is the Point of Thomson's Example Where Jones Steals