What does Thomson think that we should say about the person who leaves his window open and the innocent person who falls in through the window?
A) The man is responsible for the fall if he didn't put bars over his window
B) The man has an obligation to remove the innocent person from his house
C) Some third party has a responsibility to intervene in the subsequent conflict
D) The innocent person does not have a right to the man's house
E) The innocent person has a right to recover from her fall in the man's house

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Thomson argues that the innocent person does not have a right to the man's house simply because they fell in through the open window.

What Does Thomson Think That We Should Say About the Person