What is the difference between a rebutting objection and an undercutting objection?
A) An undercutting objection aims to show that the conclusion of another argument is false, whereas a rebutting objection only tries to show that the argument doesn't establish its conclusion.
B) A rebutting objection aims to show that the conclusion of another argument is false, whereas an undercutting objection only tries to show that the argument doesn't establish its conclusion.
C) An undercutting objection is an argument that shows that another argument commits a specific fallacy, whereas a rebutting argument aims to show that one or more premises in another argument are unacceptable or irrelevant.
D) A rebutting objection is an argument that shows that another argument commits a specific fallacy, whereas an undercutting argument aims to show that one or more premises in another argument are unacceptable or irrelevant.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

A rebutting objection directly challenges the truth of the conclusion of an argument, while an undercutting objection challenges the connection between the premises and the conclusion, suggesting that the premises do not support the conclusion as claimed.

What Is the Difference Between a Rebutting Objection and an Undercutting