The KEEPING UP WITH THE GAMBINOS objection in Chapter 8 argues that the key normative premise in the UNFAIR DISADVANTAGE argument is false. This makes KEEPING UP WITH THE GAMBINOS:
A) A rebutting objection.
B) A normative objection.
C) An undercutting objection.
D) A decisive objection.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

An undercutting objection targets the connection between an argument's premises and its conclusion, rather than directly challenging the truth of the premises themselves. By arguing that the key normative premise in the UNFAIR DISADVANTAGE argument is false, KEEPING UP WITH THE GAMBINOS undermines the support that the premise provides for the argument's conclusion, rather than directly refuting the conclusion itself. This is characteristic of an undercutting objection.

The KEEPING UP WITH THE GAMBINOS Objection in Chapter 8