In the case described by Beauchamp and Childress of a ninety-year-old patient with a squamous cell carcinoma who was extremely fearful of cancer, which of the following was NOT set forth as a justification for "intentional verbal inaccuracy" on the part of the physician who treated the patient?
A) The patient was in need of "effective reassurance."
B) The patient's family urged the physician not to tell him that the ulcer on his lip was cancer, because of the patient's fearfulness of the disease.
C) In the physician's judgment, it was "more truthful" to tell the patient he did not have cancer, because the patient was unable to accept the idea that he had a treatable and curable cancer.
D) Addressing the patient and his concerns in his own language expressed respect, not paternalistic arrogance.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of In the case described by Beauchamp and Childress of a ninety-year-old patient with a squamous cell carcinoma who was extremely fearful of cancer, which of the following was NOT set forth as a justification for "intentional verbal inaccuracy" on the part of the physician who treated the patient?
A) The patient was in need of "effective reassurance."
B) The patient's family urged the physician not to tell him that the ulcer on his lip was cancer, because of the patient's fearfulness of the disease.
C) In the physician's judgment, it was "more truthful" to tell the patient he did not have cancer, because the patient was unable to accept the idea that he had a treatable and curable cancer.
D) Addressing the patient and his concerns in his own language expressed respect, not paternalistic arrogance.

In the Case Described by Beauchamp and Childress of a Ninety-Year-Old