What are two arguments for the use of deception in scientific research, and two arguments against deception, of any kind, in research?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Two arguments for the use of deception in scientific research are:

1. Ethical considerations: Some researchers argue that deception is necessary in certain studies to maintain the integrity of the research. For example, in studies involving human behavior, participants may alter their behavior if they are aware of the true purpose of the study, leading to biased results. In these cases, deception may be necessary to ensure the validity and reliability of the research.

2. Advancing knowledge: Deception may be justified if it leads to significant advancements in scientific knowledge. Some researchers argue that the potential benefits of the research, such as understanding human behavior or developing new treatments, outweigh the ethical concerns of deceiving participants.

Two arguments against deception, of any kind, in research are:

1. Violation of autonomy: Deception in research violates the autonomy of participants by not fully informing them of the true nature of the study. This can lead to a breach of trust and undermine the voluntary nature of participation, as participants are not able to make fully informed decisions about their involvement.

2. Ethical considerations: Deception in research raises ethical concerns about the treatment of participants. It can lead to psychological harm, stress, and mistrust in the research community. Researchers have a responsibility to prioritize the well-being and rights of participants, and deception may compromise these ethical principles.

What Are Two Arguments for the Use of Deception in Scientific