What is the point of Philippa Foot's example about the lobotomized patients?
A) Lobotomies make people unhappy and therefore are to be avoided.
B) Lobotomies make people happy and therefore are to be encouraged.
C) People with lobotomies are sometimes happy, and this is evidence for hedonism.
D) People with lobotomies are sometimes happy, and this is a problem for hedonism.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Philippa Foot's example of lobotomized patients is meant to challenge the idea of hedonism, which holds that pleasure is the only intrinsic good. The example shows that although these patients may experience pleasure, their lobotomies have robbed them of their ability to have meaningful experiences and make morally relevant choices. This complicates the idea that pleasure is always a good thing and raises questions about what truly makes a life worth living.

What Is the Point of Philippa Foot's Example About the Lobotomized