Suppose that you want something very much but that when you get it, you are completely disappointed. Why does this case raise a problem for the desire satisfaction theory? What might a desire satisfaction theorist say in response? Do you find this reply convincing?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The desire satisfaction theory states that a person's well-being is determined by the satisfaction of their desires. In the case where someone wants something very much but is completely disappointed when they get it, this raises a problem for the desire satisfaction theory because it suggests that the fulfillment of desires does not always lead to well-being or satisfaction.

A desire satisfaction theorist might respond by arguing that the problem lies not with the theory itself, but with the nature of the desire. They might argue that the desire was not truly in line with the person's overall well-being or that the object of the desire did not truly fulfill the desire in the way that was expected. They might also argue that the disappointment was a result of external factors or circumstances that were beyond the control of the theory.

Whether or not this reply is convincing depends on the individual's perspective. Some may find it convincing, as it allows for the possibility that not all desires are conducive to well-being and that external factors can influence the satisfaction of desires. Others may find it unconvincing, as it does not fully address the problem of desires leading to disappointment despite being fulfilled. Ultimately, the response may not fully resolve the problem raised by the case, and further examination of the desire satisfaction theory may be necessary.

Suppose That You Want Something Very Much but That When