How might the phenomenon of a guilty conscience be used to support the theory of psychological egoism? How might the very same phenomenon be used to argue against psychological egoism? Which argument do you think is better, and why?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The phenomenon of a guilty conscience could be used to support the theory of psychological egoism by suggesting that individuals feel guilty when they act against their own self-interest. According to psychological egoism, all human actions are ultimately motivated by self-interest, and the feeling of guilt could be seen as a result of acting in a way that goes against one's own self-interest.

On the other hand, the same phenomenon could be used to argue against psychological egoism by pointing out that the feeling of guilt often arises from acting in a way that goes against societal or moral norms, rather than solely from acting against one's own self-interest. This suggests that there are motivations other than self-interest that drive human behavior.

In this case, the argument against psychological egoism seems to be stronger. The feeling of guilt is often tied to societal or moral expectations, rather than purely self-interested motivations. This suggests that there are other factors at play in human behavior, and that psychological egoism may not fully account for the complexity of human motivation. Therefore, the argument against psychological egoism is better because it takes into account the broader range of motivations that drive human behavior.

How Might the Phenomenon of a Guilty Conscience Be Used