Using the ideas put forth by Daniel Dennett, imagine you put your money in a soda machine and it doesn't give you your soda. Which of the following best represents your adopting an intentional stance toward the soda machine?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Adopting an intentional stance toward the soda machine means attributing intentionality, beliefs, desires, and rationality to the machine as if it were an agent capable of making decisions. Daniel Dennett, an American philosopher and cognitive scientist, describes the intentional stance as one of the three strategies (alongside the physical stance and the design stance) that people use to predict and explain the behavior of objects or systems.
Given the options:
a. "The cans must be jammed inside; maybe if I shake it one will come loose."
b. "Maybe it's out of everything."
c. "This machine has decided to steal my money."
d. "I personally hate this machine and I choose never to use it again."
Option c, "This machine has decided to steal my money," best represents adopting an intentional stance toward the soda machine. This is because it attributes a deliberate decision-making process to the machine, as if it had the intention to keep the money without dispensing the soda. Although this is not a rational way to interpret the behavior of a non-sentient machine, it fits the description of applying the intentional stance as defined by Dennett. Options a and b are more aligned with the design stance (considering the machine's function and possible malfunctions) and option d reflects a personal emotional reaction rather than attributing intentionality to the machine.

Using the Ideas Put Forth by Daniel Dennett, Imagine You