Gilmore claims that so-called 'brain dead' patients are either alive or dead: unlike cryptobiotic organisms, they are not 'somewhere in between'. In your own words, explain and critically evaluate his argument for this claim. Optional: Present what you take to be the best reasons in support of the opposing claim that these patients are neither alive nor dead.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Gilmore claims that so-called 'brain dead' patients are either alive or dead: unlike cryptobiotic organisms, they are not 'somewhere in between'. In your own words, explain and critically evaluate his argument for this claim. Optional: Present what you take to be the best reasons in support of the opposing claim that these patients are neither alive nor dead.

Gilmore Claims That So-Called 'Brain Dead' Patients Are Either Alive