MacDonald argues that "The contents of dreams do not appear in a context of real objects, for there are none." While it makes sense to say "I dreamed that I was riding an elephant," it would be nonsense to say ...
A) "I dreamed that I was riding a flying pink elephant."
B) "My dream of riding an elephant appeared between the window and the wardrobe."
C) "My dream connects with reality because elephants exist."
D) "I dreamed of the same thing three nights in a row."

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

MacDonald argues that dreams do not appear in a context of real objects, so it would not make sense for a dream to be located between the window and the wardrobe. This answer directly contradicts MacDonald's argument.

MacDonald Argues That "The Contents of Dreams Do Not Appear