MacDonald says that if you are asked the question, "Where did you meet Bernard Shaw?" and you answer, "In a dream," then your answer would be silly because ...
A) it locates no meeting place.
B) Bernard Shaw is dead.
C) actual people never appear in dreams as the appear in real-life.
D) you never actually met him in real-life.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The answer "in a dream" does not give a physical location where the meeting took place, making it an incomplete answer.

MacDonald Says That If You Are Asked the Question, "Where