If a claim conflicts with expert opinion, then according to the principles of critical thinking
A) the claim is false.
B) we may continue to accept the claim so long as it is consistent with our background information.
C) we have good reason to doubt the claim.
D) the claim is true.

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

When a claim conflicts with expert opinion, it raises a red flag that the claim may not be supported by the current understanding or evidence in the field, thus giving us good reason to doubt the claim. This approach aligns with critical thinking principles, which encourage skepticism and verification of information, especially when it contradicts established knowledge.

If a Claim Conflicts with Expert Opinion, Then According to the Principles