Below is a scenario that raises a moral question. Using the strategies described in Chapter 10 of Doing Practical Ethics, develop an Argument from Analogy that addresses the moral question and represent it in standard form. Then, write a brief paragraph of supplementary information for each premise (explaining what the premise is saying and why we should think it is true).
The scenario: A Psychologist's Dilemma. Zhang is a psychologist evaluating a 5-year- old boy for a learning disorder. During the process, Zhang comes to believe that the father has at times treated the boy in a way that seems just severe enough to count as reportable verbal abuse and neglect. The boy's parents are both aware that the father's parenting falls far short of ideal, and the father says he's willing to seek counseling to help him manage his flashes of anger. Zhang's position is complicated by the fact that the parents are undocumented immigrants. Reporting the father's incidents of verbal abuse to child protective services (CPS) risks exposing the parents to arrest and deportation. This would likely lead to great stress for the family, including the child. Should Zhang report the father to CPS or take some other action?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer is P1: Reporting the father's incidents of verbal abuse to CPS risks exposing the parents to arrest and deportation.

Supplementary information: This premise is stating that if Zhang were to report the father's behavior to CPS, it could potentially lead to the parents being arrested and deported due to their undocumented immigrant status. This is true because undocumented immigrants are at risk of being detained and deported if they come into contact with law enforcement or government agencies.

P2: Exposing the parents to arrest and deportation would likely lead to great stress for the family, including the child.

Supplementary information: This premise is saying that if the parents were to be arrested and deported, it would cause significant stress for the entire family, including the 5-year-old boy. This is true because the fear of separation and the uncertainty of their future can have a detrimental impact on the mental and emotional well-being of the family members.

C: Therefore, Zhang should consider taking some other action rather than reporting the father to CPS.

Supplementary information: This conclusion is suggesting that given the potential consequences of reporting the father to CPS, Zhang should explore alternative actions that could address the father's behavior without putting the family at risk of arrest and deportation. This is a reasonable conclusion because it takes into account the well-being of the entire family, including the 5-year-old boy, and seeks to avoid causing further harm to them.

Below Is a Scenario That Raises a Moral Question