Describe the ticking bomb case. Do you think the use of torture is justified in this case? Such cases are often described in such as way as to build in the assumption that the person to be tortured really has information that will in fact prevent a greater evil. In reality, when people are tortured those who are doing the torture only believe the person is guilty, only believe there is a bomb ticking away somewhere ready to cause great harm, only believe that torture will save innocent victims from this supposed harm. Are the differences between the ticking bomb case and actual real-time cases relevant to our assessment of the two types of cases?

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

The Answer of Describe the ticking bomb case. Do you think the use of torture is justified in this case? Such cases are often described in such as way as to build in the assumption that the person to be tortured really has information that will in fact prevent a greater evil. In reality, when people are tortured those who are doing the torture only believe the person is guilty, only believe there is a bomb ticking away somewhere ready to cause great harm, only believe that torture will save innocent victims from this supposed harm. Are the differences between the ticking bomb case and actual real-time cases relevant to our assessment of the two types of cases?

Describe the Ticking Bomb Case