Dr.Stewart is an editor of a psychology journal.She wants to ensure that reviewers give honest reviews of the papers they are asked to read.Which of the following could she do to increase the likelihood of honest feedback?
A)Increase the number of peer reviewers
B)Use reviewers from fields other than psychology
C)Make sure the identity of peer reviewers is unknown
D)Give reviewers a longer amount of time to read papers

Question

Quizplus · Accepted Answer

Keeping the identity of peer reviewers unknown can increase the likelihood of honest feedback because reviewers may feel more comfortable giving critical comments without fear of retribution or personal bias influencing their feedback. Increasing the number of peer reviewers or using reviewers from other fields may not necessarily lead to more honest feedback, as they may still feel pressure to provide positive comments. Giving reviewers more time to read papers may help with the quality of their feedback, but it does not necessarily increase their honesty.

DrStewart Is an Editor of a Psychology Journal